Mentor Texts: Teach Common Core Writing

Guest post By Marcie Flinchum Atkins

If you are a writing teacher, the only thing you need in your teacher toolbox is a few good books. We spend a lot of time as reading teachers making sure students are equipped with “just right” texts to read, but it’s just as important that we utilize authentic texts to help them learn to write.
If we want students to become good writers, we need to show them what good writing looks like. Using mentor texts in your classroom is a way to do that.

What is a mentor text?

A mentor text is a exemplary text used as a model for student learning. Instead of talking to kids about writing descriptions and expecting them to begin to write a description, show them how published writers use descriptions. We teach them to read like writers. We want students to learn to read for pleasure, and good readers will pick up on good writing techniques, but they will benefit even more with direct instruction. When they are writing, we want them to see how the pros stitch a story together.
Athletes study the techniques of the pros, and writers should study the techniques of the pros as well.

Where do I find mentor texts?

Start with your classroom library. You probably have books that you’ve accumulated from Scholastic Book Clubs bonus points or the ones that you bought with your meager salary. These are probably the books you know well. Use the books you’ve read as read-alouds, the books you’ve read in small groups, literature circles, or in whole group instruction.
The school and public libraries also have thousands of books. They’re stocked with newer books and classic books that you can use. ADDED NOTE: Of course, your school librarian is an invaluable resource and you should consult with him/her first!

How can I use mentor texts?

These are just some topics that I use mentor texts for:

  • Word choice—including vivid verbs, specific vocabulary, sensory words
  • Word play—onomatopeoia, puns, figurative language, made up words
  • Description—including descriptions of setting and characters
  • Beginnings and Endings
  • Organization of text—especially useful in non-fiction
  • Sentence Variety

Tips for Using Mentor Texts

  • Use picture book text with older readers. Picture books are some of the best examples of word choice available. Picture books writers have to be selective with their words, so they are perfect for teaching word play and word choice. Picture books are also short, so they can be utilized in lessons that only span one class session.

    There are dozens of teaching resource books out there that just focus on using picture books to teach writing skills. See my website for some of my favorite mentor texts).

    I am also including a sample lesson plan using a Darcy Pattison’s WISDOM, THE MIDWAY ALBATROSS, a non-fiction picture book that can be used as a mentor text.

  • Use familiar books. If you use books you and your students are already familiar with, then they are not reading for comprehension as much. They can then concentrate on the way the story is put together. For example, my students read BECAUSE OF WINN-DIXIE by Kate DiCamillo. I did the usual reading skills with the book. Instead of collecting the book when we finished, I let them hang onto it, and we used it for several writing skills. When we talked about setting and how writers describe setting in their stories, students were so familiar with BECAUSE OF WINN-DIXIE that they were able to quickly find different setting descriptions to use as mentors from DiCamillo’s book. This also makes life easier for you when you are selecting books. There is no need to invest in new books. Use the ones that you already have and are familiar with.
  • Use an excerpt from a book they haven’t read. It will be like showing a book trailer. If you entice them with highlights, they will want to read more. I use excerpts from Laura Amy Schlitz’s THE NIGHT FAIRY and Ingrid Law’s SAVVY to show students the difference that verb choices can make in creating pictures in the reader’s mind. I don’t teach these books except as mentor texts. Within minutes of using the books as mentor texts, students are making a waiting list of people who want to read the books.

What young basketball player wouldn’t love to learn how to play basketball by watching Michael Jordan? Young writers have many professional writers to mentor them. All they have to do is open up a favorite book and have a teacher help show them the way.



Marcie AtkinsMarcie Flinchum Atkins teaches fourth graders to write using mentor texts and trains teachers on how to use mentor texts in their classrooms. In the wee hours of the morning, she also writes picture books and novels. For more resources on mentor texts, check out her website: http://www.marcieatkins.com. Click on the “For Teachers” tab.


About Darcy Pattison (92 Posts)

Author, blogger and writing teacher Darcy Pattison writes about publishing, fiction and the Common Core. Published in eight languages, Pattison has written how-to-write books, picture books for children, teacher resource books and middle grade novels.


Comments

  1. Barb Gogan says:

    I think in some ways this post has good information about mentor texts and how to use them, but I couldn’t disagree more about where to find the texts.
    “Start with your classroom library. You probably have books that you’ve accumulated from Scholastic Book Clubs bonus points or the ones that you bought with your meager salary. ”
    NO! The FIRST place to find the best mentor texts is by asking your school librarian! S/he will know perhaps 20 EXCELLENT texts. And if there is something your school library doesn’t have, the school librarian has the relationship with the public library to find the text there.
    This is what school librarians are trained for and how they spend their time–finding GREAT books for Common Core, for curriculum needs, to entice reluctant readers, etc.
    Involve your school librarian at the first step of implementing Common Core–it will make your life so much easier!

    • Barb–You are absolutely right, and I’m sorry I failed to mention it. My apologies. Your school librarian is a great resource.

      • Sheila S. says:

        Marcie – Thank you for making the correction, but the simple fact that school librarians were never mentioned in your original blog post is telling. For some reason, we are often an after thought. All this money being spent on classroom libraries (they should be called “classroom collections” by the way) and book rooms…and they forget about that big room down the hallway full of books…called a LIBRARY…often managed by a professional with both a masters degree in education AND a masters degree in library and information science! I appreciate your sincere apology, I really do, but it is SO frustrating to continually be left out of the equation.

        My smart and savvy colleagues know to come to me for many projects. They leave my library very happy and loaded with great books and wonderful ideas, but I cannot speak for other teacher-librarians.

        It’s a shame. We have so very much to offer.

        Sheila H. Stafford. MSE, MLIS
        Teacher-Librarian
        Collins Elementary School
        Livingston, NJ

        • Darcy Pattison says:

          Sheila:
          Thanks for expressing your frustration with the way the Common Core is often implemented. Certainly, we support school librarians–the key to great reading in a school, in my opinion. Thank you for your advocacy and passion for connecting kids with great books.
          Darcy

  2. Mary says:

    Thanks for the blog on this topic. My favorite part–”Picture books are some of the best examples of word choice available. Picture books writers have to be selective with their words, so they are perfect for teaching word play and word choice.”

    To chime in on the issue of librarians, due to budget cuts our local school district now has part-time elementary school librarians and no high school librarians at all. Personally, I believe this is a travesty. If more teachers take advantage of the expertise of their school librarians, perhaps their importance will be more visible when budget cuts come along.

  3. kim Mahoney says:

    I think that a “classroom collection” is a great first place to look for mentor texts, especially if your classroom is packed with books! As a lover of writing and books, my classroom is bursting with books. This blog was helpful for me because I received great new ideas for teaching writing using new titles! Also, the Common Core just it my district and I’m always looking for information to improve my style and my students’ learning experience. I completely understand how invaluable a school library is and a librarian who is equally excited about books is a teacher’s best friend. However, I don’t think Marcie meant to exclude the librarians of the world. In my district, we lost our full-time librarian, so I am on my own. I’m relying on my vast collection, the public library, and my contacts on-line for books, innovative ideas, and just plain camaraderie.
    Thank you Marcie for the insight!!

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Mentor Texts: Teach Common Core Writing on Darcy Pattison’s Common Core Standards Website [...]

Speak Your Mind

*